We sought to better understand the lived experiences of Black patients presenting for evaluation in a locked psychiatric emergency unit. Our participants told us about experiences that made them feel criminalized, stigmatized and vulnerable. Our participants also expressed insight into the need for help, though they reported a mismatch between the help they hoped for and the help they received. Our participants also recognized specific helpful interventions. For individual patient interactions, we recommend a trauma-informed approach to individual patient care, with compassionate communication and clear updates regarding next steps in care. For the larger system, our findings underscore the need for interdisciplinary systemic changes to decriminalize and destigmatize the delivery of emergency psychiatric care with the overarching goal of achieving health equity.